Through-Hole PCB Assembly: Wave vs Selective, Mixed Tech, and RFQ Specs

Answer-first China PCBA guide to through-hole assembly: when THT stays on modern boards, wave vs selective vs hand, mixed SMT+THT sequence, hole-fill class, and RFQ fields that prevent quote surprises.

Last updated
Through-hole PCB assembly: insert, wave or selective solder, inspect after SMT

Through-hole technology (THT) did not disappear when SMT took over density. It stayed where mechanical anchors, high current, and vibration still beat surface pads: cable connectors that yank, power terminals that carry amps, tall magnetics and relays, and socketed parts that field techs must swap without a hot-air station. Modern China PCBA is usually mixed — SMT for ICs and passives, THT for the stress and power parts — and quotes fail when plants invent different wave versus selective maps, hole-fill classes, or insert sequences against the same BOM.

This guide answers first: when THT is still required on modern boards, the real process (insert → solder → inspect) and where it sits after SMT, a wave-versus-selective decision table with cost and DFM, IPC-A-610 Class 2 versus Class 3 hole-fill language buyers can put on a PO, the tools that matter for capability RFQs (inserters, selective, AOI — not brand fluff), and a China PCBA RFQ matrix that prevents quote surprises. SMT-vs-DIP decision depth lives on SMT vs DIP PCB assembly. End-to-end traveler context: how PCB assembly works.

Through-hole PCB assembly: insert, wave or selective solder, inspect — after SMT on mixed boards

Answer first: when THT still belongs on modern boards

Use caseWhy THT winsSMT-only risk if you force it
Panel / cable connectorsPins anchored in plated holes resist yank and mating cyclesPad peel, cracked fillets, intermittent opens
High-current powerPin cross-section and barrel copper carry amps cleanlyVia farms and copper geometry stretch; thermal stress on pads
Vibration / shockMechanical retention through the boardNeeds staking/underfill; still weaker under cable load
Field service / socketsReplaceable modules without full SMT reworkHot-air or BGA tools for every swap
Tall / odd-form partsTransformers, large electrolytics, relays fit wave/selective/handReflow profile wrong; tombstone or heat damage
Press-fit (related)Controlled press — not solder THTMis-priced as “DIP insert” → scrap housings

One-line rule: Default new digital and RF sections to SMT; keep THT where stress, current, serviceability, or odd-form thermal mass force it. Most production boards are hybrid — the RFQ must say so.

💡 Procurement Pro-Tip: List every THT refdes with intended solder method (wave / selective / hand / press-fit) before asking for unit price. “DIP capable” brochure lines do not make two China quotes comparable.

Related SMT stage detail: SMT PCB assembly process. Equipment vocabulary without brand theater: PCB assembly equipment list.

When THT stays: connectors, power pins, vibration anchors, sockets, odd-forms

Process: insert → solder → inspect (after SMT on mixed tech)

THT on a traveler is three gateable steps — not a vague “DIP line.” On mixed boards, those steps run after SMT reflow so you do not wave-heat parts that have not been placed yet, and so you can plan adhesive or selective protection for already-soldered SMT.

THT process after SMT: insert, wave/selective/hand solder, then inspect/test
StepWhat the plant doesBuyer gate to write
1. InsertAuto-insert where pitch/packaging allows; semi-auto or hand for odd-forms; clinch/hold-down if neededPin count by insert class; odd-form list; press-fit called out separately
2. SolderWave and/or selective and/or hand per pin class; flux and alloy per travelerMethod map per refdes; pallet/mask/adhesive yes-no; alloy (e.g. SAC305)
3. InspectVisual / AOI on solder side; sample or 100% per class; X-ray only if nearby SMT warrantsIPC-A-610 class; hole-fill sample plan; first-article photos of densest THT zone

Typical mixed order (confirm in writing): SMT bottom → SMT top → THT insert → wave/selective/hand → wash or no-clean → ICT/flying probe/FCT → optional coat → pack. Bottom-side SMT that must face a wave often needs adhesive or a process that never floods that side — selective is the usual escape. End-to-end gates: how PCB assembly works.

Press-fit is not step 2. Press-fit connectors need finished hole size, press equipment, and often no solder on those pins. Price them as their own line. Wave without a mask plan on press-fit neighborhoods creates bridges and cracked plastics.

⚠️ Watch Out for: Quotes that say “SMT + DIP OK” with no insert class, no solder-method map, and no inspect class. Two plants can both be capable and still deliver non-comparable prices and different hole-fill outcomes.

Wave vs selective: cost and DFM decision table

Wave floods the solder side; selective aims a nozzle or fountain at chosen pins. Hand bridges NPI and true odd-forms. Choose by pin density, nearby SMT, and scrap risk — not by which machine sounds more modern in a brochure.

Wave vs selective vs hand: pin density, SMT risk, cost, DFM fit
FactorPrefer wavePrefer selectivePrefer hand
Pin count / densityMany pins, clear wave side, similar heightsScattered THT among dense SMT; mixed heightsFew pins; ECO; prototype
Nearby SMT on solder sideSparse or protected by pallet/mask/adhesiveFine-pitch or tall SMT next to THT pinsOperator can avoid heat damage
Unit cost at volumeLowest per pin when wave side is cleanHigher per joint; often lower scrap on mixed boardsHighest labour; not a volume plan
NRE / programmingPallets, fixtures, wave profilePath program + nozzles; fixture NREMinimal NRE; skill-dependent
Alloy / process mixOne alloy across the wave sideEasier localized control; mixed process windowsFlexible but inconsistent
DFM red flagsSMT too close to pins; fine THT pitch → bridgesCannot reach shadowed pins; huge pin farms → slowProduction connector farms quoted as hand

Practical default for China mixed PCBA: wave when the solder side is mostly THT connectors/power with keep-outs; selective when bottom or solder-side SMT would cook or bridge under a full wave; hand only for odd-forms and NPI — re-quote hand farms before volume release.

DFM habits that cut both cost and scrap

  1. Group THT on one side when layout allows.
  2. Keep paste-side and solder-side SMT clear of wave neighborhoods.
  3. Call out no-solder and press-fit holes on the assembly drawing, not only in a BOM cell.
  4. Demand who owns selective path NRE and pallet design on the quote.
  5. Tie hole-fill class to the densest connector neighborhood, not to a vague “IPC capable” line.

Method comparison also appears in the SMT-vs-DIP decision page; this table is the THT-process DFM view for RFQ marking. Companion: SMT vs DIP PCB assembly.

Hole-fill Class 2 vs Class 3 — buyer language (IPC-A-610)

Hole fill is an assembly acceptance topic under IPC-A-610, not a bare-board fab class under IPC-6012. Class 2 is the usual commercial/industrial default in China when the PO is silent. Class 3 tightens vertical fill and workmanship expectations on PTH joints — and raises rework and process-window cost. Put the class on the drawing and the PO, or you will get Class 2 habit with Class 3 hope.

IPC-A-610 hole-fill Class 2 vs Class 3: buyer PO language and inspect depth
Buyer needClass 2 (typical commercial)Class 3 (high reliability / safety-critical)What to write on the PO
Vertical fill intentMore allowance for incomplete fill on some PTH joints (per cited A-610 edition)Stricter vertical fill expectations on PTH“IPC-A-610 Class X; edition YYYY”
Where it bitesConsumer/industrial I/O with known marginPower, connectors under stress, long-life, safetyOptional: “Class 3 on J1–J3 only”
Inspection depthSample visual / AOI commonDeeper sample or 100% on critical joints; FA photosSample plan + FA photo of densest THT zone
Process impactWave often sufficient if DFM cleanMay force selective, tighter flux/profile, more rework loopsMethod map must support the class
Cost driverLower scrap allowance spendHigher process control and potential reworkDo not Class-3 the whole board if only three connectors need it

Buyer one-liner: Class is contractual acceptance, not a plant badge. “We do Class 3” without A-610 on the PO is marketing. Bare-board Class 3 (annular ring, plating) is a different document family — see IPC Class 3 PCB fabrication when fab class is also in scope.

⚠️ Watch Out for: Citing “IPC Class 3” with no document number, or putting A-610 Class 3 on a fab-only PO. Split fab class (6012/A-600) from assembly class (A-610) when both appear in one turnkey RFQ.

Tools that matter for RFQ capability (no brand fluff)

Capability questions should name process roles, not catalog logos. Brands change; the traveler does not.

Tool roleWhat it proves on a THT jobAsk in the RFQ
Axial / radial / odd-form insertersAuto-insert capacity vs hand-insert bottleneckMax pin rate; which packages auto vs hand
Wave solder systemVolume pin flooding with pallets/masksPallet/mask available? Max board size? Alloy
Selective solder (nozzle/fountain)Localized joints next to SMTPath NRE owner; nozzles for your pin pitch
Press-fit press (if any)Controlled force — not solderHole-size tolerance window; press tonnage class
Solder-side AOI / visual stationHole-fill and bridge detection after THTCoverage %; Class 2 vs 3 criteria loaded?
ICT / flying probe / FCTElectrical proof after mixed solderFixture ownership; coverage rules

Machine-by-machine context for the whole PCBA line: PCB assembly equipment list. Do not let a brand list replace the method map and class callouts above.

China PCBA RFQ matrix for through-hole (and mixed) jobs

Paste these fields so every bidder answers the same traveler. Brochure “DIP OK” fails here; comparable quotes survive.

RFQ fieldWhy it mattersExample answer format
THT pin count by methodDrives insert + solder time and NRE“90 wave; 16 selective; 3 hand odd-form; 0 press-fit”
Wave vs selective vs hand mapMakes unit prices comparableTraveler mark-up per THT refdes
Hole-fill / IPC-A-610 classVertical fill and workmanship“A-610 Class 2; Class 3 on J1–J2”
Mixed sequenceHeat budget and adhesive need“SMT both sides → selective THT → no-clean → FCT”
Adhesive / pallet / maskDouble-sided mixed survival“Glue bottom SMT” or “selective only — no wave”
Press-fit present?Separate process, not solder THT“Press-fit J4; finished hole per vendor PN”
Alloy + flux / washStops SnPb-by-habit; coat compatibility“SAC305; no-clean; wash if coat follows”
Inspect / test after THTCoverage after mixed solder“Solder-side AOI 100% connectors; flying probe NPI”
Selective / pallet NRE ownerHidden cost and schedule“Customer pays path NRE” or “included in setup”
Coat after solder?Coat never before THT solder“Conformal coat after wash/dry; keep-outs on drawing”

Also attach: BOM lines flagged THT vs SMT, CPL for SMT, assembly drawing with polarity and keep-outs, and whether the kit is turnkey or consignment (connectors are often long-lead). Sourcing model depth: full turnkey vs consignment PCB assembly when that page is in your set; otherwise lock kit ownership on line 1 of the RFQ.

Design habits that keep THT quotes honest

  1. Flag every THT and press-fit refdes on the assembly drawing.
  2. Size pads and holes for the stated A-610 class before RFQ.
  3. Keep SMT clearances around wave neighborhoods.
  4. Re-quote hand-soldered pilots before volume — pin-minutes on a bench are not a process plan.
  5. Demand first-article solder-side photos of the densest THT zone plus the sample plan tied to class.

Through-hole PCB assembly FAQ

When is through-hole (THT) still required on modern PCBs?

Keep THT for connectors that take cable yank or mating cycles, high-current power pins, vibration-critical anchors, socketed field-replaceable parts, and tall odd-forms (transformers, large electrolytics, relays) that do not belong in reflow. Prefer SMT for density, automation, and most digital/RF sections. Most China PCBA is mixed SMT + THT.

What is the usual THT process order on mixed SMT + THT boards?

SMT first (often bottom then top with reflow), then THT insertion, then wave and/or selective and/or hand solder, then wash or no-clean, then inspect/test and optional conformal coat. Confirm adhesive or pallets when bottom SMT must survive wave heat. Press-fit is a separate process -?not solder THT.

Wave soldering vs selective soldering -?which should I choose?

Wave is lowest cost per pin when many THT pins face a clear solder side. Selective is the better default when dense or fine-pitch SMT sits next to THT pins and a full wave would cook or bridge them. Hand solder fits odd-forms and NPI; treat hand as a volume plan for connector farms as a capability gap, not a bargain.

What hole-fill class should I put on the PO (IPC-A-610)?

IPC-A-610 Class 2 is the usual commercial/industrial default in China when the PO is silent. Class 3 tightens vertical fill and workmanship on PTH joints and raises process/rework cost -?use it for stress/power/safety-critical connectors, or Class 3 on named refdes only. Cite A-610 and the edition; do not confuse assembly class with bare-board IPC-6012 Class 3.

Which tools matter for a China THT capability RFQ?

Ask for process roles, not brand logos: axial/radial/odd-form inserters, wave with pallets/masks, selective solder (path NRE owner), press-fit press if needed, solder-side AOI/visual for hole fill, and ICT/flying probe/FCT coverage rules. Pair tools with a pin-method map and A-610 class -?a machine list alone does not make quotes comparable.

What RFQ fields prevent through-hole quote surprises?

Require THT pin count by method (wave/selective/hand/press-fit), a traveler mark-up per refdes, IPC-A-610 hole-fill class, mixed SMT→THT sequence, adhesive/pallet/mask need, alloy and wash/coat order, inspect/test after THT, and who owns selective or pallet NRE. Same zip and same locks to every bidder.